As I just watched the Super Bowl performance by Madonna (which was, by no uncertain terms, an amazing show), I was very disappointed to notice she was obviously lip-synching during the performance. Actually, everyone was.
Through my disappointment, I thought back to the once big-time, now has-beens that have died by the ever unforgiving hand of the Lip-Synch performance. Milli Vanilli, Britney Spears and Ashley Simpson come to mind immediately. While they were not a part of a Super Bowl half-time show when their discretion happened, it still meant their career was in the hands of fans that obviously felt used and upset at the thought of being duped.
So, is it fair to say that under any circumstances lip-synching could end up being a marketing disaster? I’ll get to my opinion further down in a minute, but first I want to play devil’s advocate. I do believe the Super Bowl, no matter where it is held, would be a very hard place to not have a recorded version of your performance being played during the live show. I will give them that. From acoustics to the many things that could go wrong, and sometimes do go wrong (which, from a marketing stand-point has made the half-time show such a must-see attraction on some level).
However, as the American public may innately feel, we are paying or tuning in to watch LIVE football and in turn expect the entire experience to be just that…a LIVE performance.
I am not sure that a portion of the American psyche, for the most part, will ever be able to get over feeling as if they have been ripped-off by a performance that is recorded and not live at one of the most important live performances of American culture-The Super Bowl.
As I watched Madonna’s performance, I felt a strong let down come over me. Sure she is not young, but she is not old either. I felt not only ripped off by the recorded version I heard coming through my television, but I also felt a tinge of regret that if she could not perform without lip-synching because of the moves and the sheer intensity of the choreography, then I feel she was not showing truly, nor was she embracing, her age and what she is capable of doing..which is being an incredibly talented, amazing middle-aged woman.
I was let down. Pure and simple. It was flashy, but it wasn’t indicative of my generation, which is Madonna’s generation.
So, a marketing mistake? This marketer feels the answer is yes. Absolutely. It was her time to show her stuff, as it would be any artist, and to do it live.. which is what the Super Bowl is all about. Instead, she sold out and expected the American Public to buy it. I will always adore Madonna, and I doubt very seriously she will ever go the way of Milli Vanilli, Britney or Ashley Simpson, but to say this helped her career from a marketing standpoint, this author gives her and her reps an F.



One of Advance Marketing’s specialties is creating commercials to help businesses market their brand.